1. United States
2. Va.
3. Letter

I am writing in opposition of H.R.9462 - Educational Choice for Children Act and S.120 - Educational Choice for Children Act. This legislation will spend $5 billion a year in taxpayer funds, totaling $20 billion over a four-year period, creating a system for privileging certain charities over others. They prioritize donations to private schools over charities that address other issues, such as food banks, churches, and homelessness shelters. The benefit for donating to private schools would be 2-3 times more than other charitable organizations, according to the National Coalition for Public Education. Despite private schools being able to discriminate against different student groups, such as those with disabilities and LGBTQ+ students, the legislation offers no protections for students. Notably, the only mention of non-discrimination in the bill language is about ensuring religious private schools are eligible for the same benefits as secular private schools. The legislation offers two opportunities for discrimination against students: the scholarship granting organizations, which also take a cut of the money, can discriminate against the students they choose to provide vouchers to, and the private schools can discriminate against the students they choose to accept into their schools. It is difficult to justify spending $20 billion to create a new federal system for private education when we have a public education system struggling with a lack of funds. This proposal further defunds public education at a troubling time for our nation’s schools. The drop in pandemic relief funding, combined with state tax cuts, inflation, and existing state voucher programs has caused schools across the country to consider mass layoffs, program cuts, and even school closures. For all of these reasons, I am asking for you to oppose this legislation as it makes its way through congress, as well as any similar legislation introduced in the 1119th congress. Thank you.